Quick Navigation
“Why IIM?” seems straightforward—until you realize that every candidate says “brand,” “alumni network,” and “placements.” The real question panels are asking is: Why THIS IIM specifically, and why are you the right fit for US?
The why IIM interview answer tests whether you’ve done genuine research or are simply chasing prestige. Panels at IIM-A, IIM-B, and IIM-C each want to hear something different—and confusing their identities is an instant credibility killer.
This guide focuses specifically on IIM differentiation and the “why not another school” trap. For the complete school-fit pattern covering all B-schools, see: Why This B-School Interview Answer: Beyond Generic Platitudes
What Panels Are Really Evaluating
When IIM panels ask “Why us?”, they’re assessing four qualities:
- Research Depth: Have you actually studied this specific school, or are you giving a template answer?
- Goal-School Alignment: Does what we offer match what you need for your stated career goals?
- Contribution Potential: What will you add to our classroom, clubs, and campus culture?
- Genuine Interest: If we select you and you get multiple admits, will you actually join us?
School-choice questions come in several forms, each probing a slightly different angle.
Direct “Why This School” Questions
- “Why IIM Ahmedabad/Bangalore/Calcutta specifically?”
- “What do you know about our program?”
- “Which courses or centers interest you here?”
- “How will you contribute to our campus?”
- “Have you spoken to any of our alumni?”
“Why Not Another School” Comparisons
- “Why IIM-A and not IIM-B?” / “Why IIM-B and not IIM-A?”
- “If you get both IIM-A and XLRI, which will you choose?”
- “Why not ISB—their one-year program might suit your experience level?”
- “FMS costs a fraction of our fee. Why pay more for us?”
- “Why not do an MBA abroad instead?”
Commitment-Testing Questions
- “What if you get into IIM-A but not us? Will you take it?”
- “Are we your first choice? Why?”
- “You seem like an ISB profile. Why are you here?”
- “How serious are you about joining us specifically?”
Follow-Up Probes
- “That’s what everyone says. What’s unique about YOUR reason?”
- “Which specific professor/course are you referring to?”
- “Have you researched what we actually offer for [your goal]?”
- “Our placement data shows we’re not strong in [your stated goal]. Why still us?”
- “IIM has great brand value”
- “The alumni network is amazing”
- “Placements are excellent”
- “Case-based pedagogy is world-class”
- “Peer learning from diverse batch”
Why it fails: All of this applies to every IIM and most top B-schools. If your answer works by just changing the school name, it’s not an answer—it’s a template. Panels have heard this hundreds of times today.
- Name specific courses that align with your goals
- Mention centers, clubs, or initiatives unique to this IIM
- Reference specific faculty or research areas
- Share insights from alumni conversations
- Connect your background to their specific strengths
Why it works: Specificity proves research. When you name a course, professor, or center that’s genuinely unique to that IIM, you prove you’ve done homework.
- “IIM-A is ranked #1 in India”
- “You’re consistently in the top 3”
- “NIRF rankings show you’re the best”
- “Everyone knows IIM-A is the best brand”
Why it fails: Rankings don’t explain fit. If you chose IIM-A just because it’s #1, you’ll leave the moment something better comes along. It also implies you don’t understand what differentiates schools beyond prestige.
- Focus on program-specific strengths, not rankings
- Explain why their specific offerings match your goals
- Show you understand what makes them different, not just “better”
- Connect their unique features to your career trajectory
Why it works: Panels want to see you chose them for fit, not just prestige. Understanding their differentiation shows mature decision-making.
- “XLRI is too HR-focused for my goals”
- “ISB is just one year—not enough depth”
- “FMS has poor infrastructure”
- “IIM-B’s location isn’t as good as IIM-A”
Why it fails: Criticizing other schools to praise this one is risky. The panelist might be an alumnus of the school you just criticized. It also suggests you make decisions by elimination rather than attraction.
- Praise what draws you TO this school, not what pushes you FROM others
- If asked to compare directly, be diplomatic: “Both are excellent, but X specifically offers…”
- Focus on positive differentiation, not negative comparison
- Acknowledge other schools’ strengths while explaining your preference
Why it works: Positive framing shows you’re attracted by strengths, not repelled by weaknesses. It’s more mature and less risky.
The F.I.T. framework ensures your answer demonstrates genuine alignment between your goals and the school’s offerings.
-
F
Features (Specific to This School)Name 2-3 specific offerings that are unique or particularly strong at THIS school: courses, centers, clubs, exchange programs, pedagogy style, or research areas. “IIM-A’s Centre for Innovation Incubation and Entrepreneurship (CIIE) and courses like ‘New Venture Creation’ directly address my goal of building a tech-enabled logistics startup.”
-
I
Integration (Connection to Your Goals)Explain how these specific features connect to YOUR career goals and background. This is the bridge. “Coming from 3 years in supply chain at Flipkart, I’ve identified specific operational challenges that CIIE’s startup ecosystem and the supply chain electives here would help me address systematically.”
-
T
Two-Way Value (What You’ll Contribute)Show it’s mutual: what will YOU bring to the classroom, club, or campus? “I’d contribute my operational experience to case discussions and hope to be active in E-Cell. I’ve already connected with two alumni who mentioned the entrepreneurship community here would value practitioners with supply chain depth.”
Mentioning conversations with alumni is powerful: “I spoke with [Name], PGP 2019, who told me about…” This proves genuine interest (you took time to reach out), gives you insider insights to reference, and shows the school you’re already building network connections. If you haven’t spoken to alumni yet, start now—it’s one of the strongest differentiators.
Handling “What If You Get Both?” Questions
When asked “If you get both IIM-A and IIM-B, which will you choose?”, use this structure:
- Acknowledge both are excellent: “Both are outstanding programs, and I’d be fortunate to get either.”
- State your preference with specific reasons: “For my specific goals in [X], IIM-[A/B] offers [specific feature] that aligns better because [reason].”
- Avoid ranking language: Don’t say “A is better than B.” Say “A is a better fit for me because…”
- Show you’ve thought about it: Reference specific conversations or research that informed your preference.
Each IIM has distinct characteristics. Use these differentiation points to craft school-specific answers.
| IIM | Key Differentiators | Mention If Your Goal Is… |
|---|---|---|
| IIM Ahmedabad | CIIE (entrepreneurship), case-based pedagogy pioneer, strategic consulting strength, Ahmedabad textile/pharma ecosystem | Entrepreneurship, consulting, general management leadership |
| IIM Bangalore | Tech/startup ecosystem proximity, strong tech placements, NSRCEL (innovation center), analytics focus | Product management, tech consulting, startups, analytics |
| IIM Calcutta | Finance/consulting strength, quant rigor, Joka culture, strong international placements | Investment banking, finance, consulting, quant roles |
| IIM Lucknow | Operations/supply chain strength, Noida campus for working executives, strong FMCG placements | Operations, supply chain, FMCG, manufacturing |
| IIM Kozhikode | Marketing strength, LIVE projects, beautiful campus, strong South India network | Marketing, sales, brand management |
| IIM Indore | Mumbai campus for executives, IPM program (integrated), media/entertainment placements | Media, entertainment, marketing, working professional track |
Sample Answers by IIM
“IIM is the best B-school in India. The brand value, alumni network, and placements are unmatched. Case-based learning will help me develop managerial skills, and peer learning from a diverse batch will broaden my perspective.”
F: “IIM-A’s CIIE and the entrepreneurship ecosystem here specifically drew me. The ‘New Venture Creation’ and ‘Managing Family Business’ courses address gaps I’ve identified in my own family’s manufacturing business.”
I: “I’m third-generation in a â‚ą150Cr auto-components business. We’re facing professionalization challenges as we scale. CIIE’s work with family businesses and the alumni network in manufacturing—I spoke with Amit Sharma, PGP 2018, who transitioned his family business post-MBA—showed me IIM-A understands this transition.”
T: “I’d contribute operational insights from running a factory floor and hope to be active in the Entrepreneurship Cell. My experience with supplier negotiations and working capital management could add practical depth to case discussions.”
F: “IIM-B’s proximity to the Bangalore tech ecosystem and NSRCEL’s work with tech startups aligns perfectly with my goal. The Data Science and Analytics electives, plus courses on ‘Digital Business Models,’ address exactly the skills I need.”
I: “I’ve spent 4 years as a product manager at a mid-stage fintech. My gap is the business strategy layer—understanding unit economics, scaling decisions, and stakeholder management. IIM-B’s strong PM placements and the tech-first culture mean I’ll be surrounded by people who understand my context.”
T: “I’d bring practical product experience to case discussions—I’ve shipped 3 products to production. I’m also interested in contributing to Product Club and mentoring in NSRCEL, given my background in fintech product development.”
F: “IIM-C’s strength in finance and the quant rigor of the program—I’ve heard Joka is particularly demanding on the analytics front—matches my interest in investment banking. The Finance Lab and courses like ‘Derivatives’ and ‘Fixed Income’ would build the technical depth I need.”
I: “As a CA with 3 years in Big 4 transaction advisory, I have the accounting foundation but lack the modeling and valuation rigor that IB requires. IIM-C’s track record in placing candidates in BB banks, combined with the Finance Club’s case competitions, would help me bridge that gap.”
T: “My deal experience—I’ve worked on 8 M&A transactions—would add practical context to valuation discussions. I’d also hope to contribute to Finance Club by bringing live deal case studies to workshops.”
For each IIM you’re interviewing at, prepare: (1) 2-3 specific courses aligned with your goals, (2) 1-2 centers or clubs you’d engage with, (3) At least 1 alumni conversation to reference, (4) 1 specific contribution you’d make. This preparation takes 2-3 hours per school but transforms your answer from generic to compelling.
Frequently Asked Questions
Quick Revision: Key Concepts
Crafting the Perfect Why IIM Interview Answer
The why IIM interview answer is one of the most frequently asked questions at IIM personal interviews—and one of the most commonly bungled. When panels at IIM Ahmedabad, Bangalore, or Calcutta ask “Why us?”, they’re not looking for generic praise about brand value and alumni networks. They want to see genuine research, specific alignment between your goals and their offerings, and clarity on what you’ll contribute.
Beyond the Generic: Why This B-School Interview Specificity
The why this b-school interview question fails when answers could apply to any school by just changing the name. “Great faculty, excellent placements, strong alumni network” describes every top B-school. Success requires naming specific courses, centers, clubs, or research areas unique to that IIM—and explaining how they connect to your career goals.
Handling the “Why IIM Not XLRI” Comparison
The why IIM not XLRI or “why not ISB” questions are traps if you criticize other schools. Instead, focus on positive differentiation: what draws you TO this school, not what pushes you FROM others. “XLRI is excellent for HR, but my interest in general management consulting makes IIM-A’s case pedagogy a better fit” works. “XLRI is too HR-focused” doesn’t.
IIM Interview School Choice: The F.I.T. Framework
For any IIM interview school choice question, use the F.I.T. framework: Features (specific to this school), Integration (connection to your goals), and Two-Way Value (what you’ll contribute). This structure ensures you demonstrate genuine alignment while showing you’ll add value to their classroom and campus.
Preparing Your Why IIM Ahmedabad Answer
A strong why IIM Ahmedabad answer references CIIE (Centre for Innovation Incubation and Entrepreneurship), specific courses like ‘New Venture Creation,’ the Ahmedabad ecosystem for manufacturing/textiles, or alumni conversations. For IIM-B, mention NSRCEL, the Bangalore tech ecosystem, and PM/analytics placements. For IIM-C, reference the Finance Lab, quant rigor, and “Joka culture.” Each school has distinct strengths—your job is to know them and connect them to your goals.
The Alumni Advantage
The most powerful differentiator in school-choice answers is referencing alumni conversations: “I spoke with [Name], PGP 2019, who shared…” This proves genuine interest, provides insider insights to reference, and shows you’re already building connections. If you haven’t connected with alumni yet, make it a priority—it transforms your answer from generic to compelling.